Ways to use this list
- Morning circle with 5 to 7 year olds: read the question, then children shuffle to the window side or the door side of the rug to show their choice.
- Persuasive writing in Years 3 to 6: draw a Thinking question and have pupils write "I would rather… because…" with three reasons.
- Small-group talk: questions like lots of friends or one best friend help a quiet child explain what matters to them, with no right answer to get wrong.
- Smart board warm-ups: put the card draw in fullscreen and let the class vote with thumbs up for the first choice and thumbs down for the second.
- Bedtime: one silly question each night soon becomes a small ritual that young children ask for by name.
Press Draw a card, tap the game or press the Space bar. Change the list in the box as you
like: add your own, delete what doesn't suit you, or write *2 after an entry to give it double the
chance. The game buttons switch the same list to a wheel, duck race, hat and more.
The full list (41 entries)
- Would you rather have a tail or whiskers?
- Would you rather bounce everywhere or slide everywhere?
- Would you rather have spaghetti hair or marshmallow fingers?
- Would you rather sneeze glitter or burp bubbles?
- Would you rather be as small as a mouse or as big as a house?
- Would you rather have a glowing nose or whistling ears?
- Would you rather live in a giant shoe or a giant teapot?
- Would you rather have a kangaroo pouch or a giraffe neck?
- Would you rather only whisper or only shout?
- Would you rather ride a dolphin or a dragon?
- Would you rather have a pet dinosaur or a pet octopus?
- Would you rather eat broccoli ice cream or chocolate-covered carrots?
- Would you rather walk backwards all day or hop all day?
- Would you rather be a cat for a day or a bird for a day?
- Would you rather have rainbow skin or polka-dot hair?
- Would you rather sleep on a bed of jelly or a bed of clouds?
- Would you rather swim in custard or jump into a pile of feathers?
- Would you rather talk like a duck or walk like a duck?
- Would you rather fit in a pocket or grow as tall as a tree?
- Would you rather have a talking backpack or flying shoes?
- Would you rather live in a lighthouse or a windmill?
- Would you rather have a snow day every week or a beach day every week?
- Would you rather have eyes in the back of your head or stretchy arms?
- Would you rather wear pyjamas to school or a cape to bed?
- Would you rather laugh like a hyena or snort like a pig?
- Would you rather have crayons for fingers or paintbrushes for toes?
- Would you rather smell like popcorn or like roses all day?
- Would you rather have a teacher who sings everything or one who raps it?
- Would you rather count to a thousand or say the alphabet backwards ten times?
- Would you rather have lots of friends or one best friend?
- Would you rather be the best at drawing or the best at singing?
- Would you rather know every answer in maths or every word in the dictionary?
- Would you rather be a famous inventor or a famous explorer?
- Would you rather be really patient or really brave?
- Would you rather have a robot that does homework or one that tidies your room?
- Would you rather play outside all day or build things inside all day?
- Would you rather win every game or never feel bored?
- Would you rather help animals or help people when you grow up?
- Would you rather be the youngest in your family or the oldest?
- Would you rather have a quiet birthday with one friend or a big party?
- Would you rather learn to fly a plane or sail a ship?
📖 Related guide: Who goes first? 12 fair ways to decide
Questions people ask
What makes a good would you rather question for kids?
Two choices that are both a little wonderful or both a little gross, so there is no obvious winner. Arguing about why is the best part, and it is surprisingly good thinking practice.
Can I print these would you rather questions?
The full list is written out further down this page, so you can print it from your browser or copy it into a worksheet. Cut the questions into strips for a jar on the classroom shelf.
How do I use these questions to teach reasoning?
Ask every child to finish the sentence "I would rather… because…", then invite one child from each side to change someone's mind. Thinking ones work best, since both answers have real reasons.
How is this different from the would you rather wheel?
The would you rather wheel mixes questions for every age, teens and adults included. These were written for children, with sillier choices and simpler words.